New York Governor Kathy Hochul Aims to Curb Retail Theft with Suggested Changes to Discovery Laws

##

Gov. Hochul’s Crusade on Discovery Laws

In the heart of the bustling Empire State, Governor Kathy Hochul is very much on a mission. She’s been tirelessly championing changes to our criminal discovery laws—because something’s gotta give. Flanked by top-dog district attorneys and a squad of business bigwigs, she’s throwing down the gauntlet to tackle retail theft head-on.

###

Unpacking the Discovery Law Debacle

Now, let’s break it down. “Discovery” isn’t just some law-talk mumbo jumbo. It’s about fairness, making sure both prosecutors and defense attorneys share evidence before the courtroom showdown. But hold on, there’s a hitch. The original 2019 reforms, let’s say, have left a few loopholes wide open.

Since then, dismissal rates in NYC have skyrocketed. Back in 2019, larceny dismissals stood at 3,385. Fast forward to 2024, and that number’s a jaw-dropping 7,168. It begs the question, where’s the justice?

###

Backing the Movement

Hochul ain’t in this alone, though. Richmond County’s sharp-witted District Attorney, Michael E. McMahon, [backs her efforts to the hilt](https://www.silive.com/crime-safety/2025/04/staten-island-community-boards-civic-groups-back-gov-hochuls-proposed-discovery-law-reform.html). Heck, 14 civic groups are cheering her on, too. And it’s no surprise, considering the stakes.

###

The Five-Point Plan to Curb Retail Theft

Last year, Hochul rubber-stamped a plan throwing more than $40 million at this issue. Aimed at tackling organized retail theft, it lays out several strategies:

– Dedicated retail theft teams within law enforcement
– A $5 million tax credit for small biz owners to beef up security
– Upping the ante for assaulting retail workers from a misdemeanor to a felony

But wait—there’s more! Her proposed legislative tweaks dream of reducing case backlogs, shortening pretrial jails stints, and shielding witness info like a well-kept secret.

###

Rallying the Lawmakers

Legislators exchanging heated words about the state budget—what’s new? But in this face-off, Hochul is clear as crystal, declaring, “Retail theft’s public enemy number one!” She’s determined to prioritize affordability and safety in the budget discussions.

“We’re not letting loopholes hole up our progress,” she avows. What she wants is accountability served hot and fast, like a New York slice.

###

McMahon’s Perspective

McMahon’s got his two cents ready. “Technicalities shouldn’t let retail theft recidivists off the hook,” he says. To him, it’s not just about slapping a sentence, but restoring justice to victims’ lives. Hochul’s proposed changes, he notes, are the light at the end of New York’s tunnel of crime and punishment.

When the dust settles on these negotiations, McMahon’s grateful for Hochul’s steadfast partnership. The vision? A New York with fair-handed, open, and downright transparent justice laws—the kind of justice its citizens deserve.

As this saga unfurls, one thing’s for sure: the Big Apple, after all, never shies away from tackling its biggest challenges head-on.